1st period

• 05:50
  TORA. Matthews(19)PP

  M. Marner (17), W. Nylander (20)

  TOR 1–0 NYI
• 09:20
  NYIB. Nelson(12)TYING

  K. Palmieri (9), N. Dobson (20)

  TOR 1–1 NYI
• 18:33
  NYIC. Cizikas(4)

  C. Clutterbuck (5), H. Fasching (3)

  TOR 1–2 NYI

2nd period

• 01:10
  NYIK. Palmieri(8)

  B. Nelson (10), N. Dobson (21)

  TOR 1–3 NYI
• 07:43
  TORJ. Tavares(8)

  C. Timmins (3), J. McCabe (5)

  TOR 2–3 NYI

3rd period

• 19:53
  TORM. Rielly(4)TYING

  J. Tavares (17), W. Nylander (21)

  TOR 3–3 NYI

Overtime 1

• 00:46
  NYIB. Horvat(10)

  M. Barzal (20), N. Dobson (22)

  TOR 3–4 NYI