1st period

• 19:12
  ATLM. Afinogenov(1)

  N. Bergfors (1), N. Antropov (1)

  ATL 1–0 PIT

2nd period

• 12:05
  PITE. Malkin(1)TYINGPP

  A. Goligoski (1), S. Crosby (1)

  ATL 1–1 PIT
• 17:23
  ATLT. Stapleton(1)PP

  J. Oduya (1), T. Enstrom (1)

  ATL 2–1 PIT

3rd period

• 03:27
  PITT. Kennedy(1)TYING

  S. Gonchar (1), S. Crosby (2)

  ATL 2–2 PIT
• 04:31
  ATLR. Peverley(1)

  C. MacArthur (1), E. Kane (1)

  ATL 3–2 PIT
• 18:46
  PITS. Gonchar(1)TYINGPP

  E. Malkin (1), A. Goligoski (2)

  ATL 3–3 PIT

Overtime 1

• 02:50
  PITJ. Leopold(1)

  S. Crosby (3)

  ATL 3–4 PIT